I am always intrigued when creative people tread common
territory. I’m not talking about plagiarism, mind you, just coincidental mining
of similar themes. I ran across just such a case recently while I was reading
an old issue of WEIRD TALES MAGAZINE – actually, it was a Weird Tales paperback
book, the 4-issue series Edited by Lin Carter. It was in issue 2, a story
called FEAR by JOSEPH PAYNE BRENNAN.
It is one of Brennan’s supernatural detective stories
featuring detective Lucius Leffing, on a case in Connecticut with his assistant.
Here’s the plot – Leffing and partner have been called to investigate a series
of strange deaths at the Hemlock Hills Convalescent Center. Turns out a
supernatural being is stalking the halls of the nursing home, and the patients
are dying of fright at the sight of the hideous being.
I was, of course, immediately reminded of BUBBA HOTEP, written by
Joe R. Lansdale and filmed by Don Coscarelli. Perhaps the only similar element between the two stories is a
supernatural entity in a nursing home, but that in and of itself is pretty
significant. Beyond that the two stories diverge pretty widely, and Lansdale’s
plot features a retired Elvis Presley in place of a supernatural detective. The
actual monster is different, too – it’s an ancient mummy in the Lansdale story,
while here it is the physical manifestation of a witch who was burned alive 200
years prior. Still, the description isn’t that far off from ole Bubba H. –
“The air appeared to shift and waver and the ghastly remains
of a face, little more than a blackened skull with shreds of shriveled flesh,
etched itself immediately in front of me. Puffy lips writhed away from a
toothless mouth set in a rictus of final agony. The red, glazing eyes seemed to
reflect fire; they glared from the wrecked face with an expression of ultimate
fear and ferocious hatred which I hope never to see again.”
Brennan and Lansdale were definitely
both inspired by the depressing and oppressive nature of retirement homes, and
the constant companion of death that always lingers nearby. Makes for an interesting
study in similarities between the two tales.
